Back to Games
The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing box art

Expansion for The Plum Island Horror

The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing

Kritiku rating

Not rated

—

How good an addition this is to The Plum Island Horror

Your rating

—

Sign in to rate this expansion

Published
2025
Reach
Niche (via base game)
Players
1–4
Play time
60–180 min
Weight
Not enough ratings yet
Ratings
0

How it plays

No rules summary yet for this game.

Main mechanics

  • Co-operative
  • Co-operative: Everyone wins or loses together against the game.
Full publisher description

A new eye-witness source to the atrocities of Plum Island has come forward to tell their story and let's just say, if you thought the event seemed bad before, you're going to want to take a seat for this because that was nothing compared to the nightmares that they shared. After countless hours of reviewing new information and consuming an unquantifiable amount of caffeinated beverages, the team that brought you The Plum Island Horror is back with a new expansion chock-full with . . . well . . . more of a bad thing. More of a Bad Thing introduces: Three new playable Factions New Scenarios including a Nightmare Mode that significantly ratchets up the difficulty New Mutations, Search cards, Fate Cards, and Events Location manipulation and much more description from the publisher

How this expansion changes the base game

ComplexityNo change
Much lighterNo changeMuch heavier
DepthNo change
Much shallowerNo changeMuch deeper
SkillNo change
Much more luckNo changeMuch more skill
InteractionNo change
Much lessNo changeMuch more
Table ExpNo change
Much worseNo changeMuch better
Integration / RefinementNot rated yet
Makes it worseNo changeEssential
  • Community rating
  • Your rating

Base vs with this expansion

See how this expansion changes the base game across the six criteria. The farther a line reaches from the centre, the higher that criterion scores.

ComplexityDepthSkillInteractionTable ExpProduction

No ratings yet — be the first to shape this game's profile.